DESTINAZIONE EUROPA. BOARDING PASS PER LE MARIE CURIE FELLOWSHIP Focus sul capitolo B5 IMPACT

Transcript

1 A P R E A G E N Z I A P E R L A PROMOZIONE D E L L A R I C E R C A E U R O P E A DESTINAZIONE EUROPA BOARDING PASS PER LE MARIE CURIE FELLOWSHIP Focus sul capitolo B5 IMPACT Di Angelo D Agostino con la collaborazione di Katia Insogna APRE Notizie Inserto N. 5 Giugno 2013

2 Gentili Soci, dal mese di febbraio il mensile APRE NOTIZIE sarà accompagnato sino a giugno 2013 da un inserto di approfondimento sull Azione Marie Curie "Intra-European Fellowships for Career Development" (IEF). I 5 inserti Destinazione Europa Boarding pass per le Marie Curie Fellowship riassumono l esperienza maturata dai Punti di contatto Nazionale APRE e la mettono a disposizione della rete dei Soci APRE che intendono accogliere un ricercatore e ai loro ricercatori che intendono maturare un esperienza europea. Questa iniziativa infatti intende fornire alla rete dei Soci APRE degli strumenti per redigere una proposta di successo e posizionarsi ai primi posti delle liste di finanziamento. La scelta è caduta sull azione "Intra-European Fellowships for Career Development" poiché è la misura che riceve un numero maggiore di proposte tra le iniziative Marie Curie. I singoli inserti forniscono nel dettaglio una serie di raccomandazioni utili per ciascun criterio di valutazione: S&T Quality Training Researcher Implementation Impact Per ogni criterio vengono rilevati i maggiori punti di forza e di debolezza dei progetti presentati, derivanti da un attenta analisi degli Evaluation Summary Report (ESR) degli ultimi anni di bando e dai risultati dell esperienza maturata dai National Contact Points (NCP) PEOPLE attraverso il servizio di prescreening delle proposte progettuali. Numeri arretrati: B1. S&T quality (febbraio 2013) B2. Training (marzo 2013) B3. RESEARCHER B4. IMPLEMENTATION Se hai perso un numero puoi richiederlo direttamente al Referente Soci del tuo ente: APRE 2013 Riproduzione vietata ai sensi di legge (art. 171 della legge 22 aprile 1941, n. 633) Tutti i diritti sono riservati. E vietata la riproduzione anche parziale del materiale con qualsiasi mezzo, senza previa autorizzazione scritta di APRE o senza che sia citata la fonte (Agenzia per la Promozione della Ricerca Europea). E fatto salvo il caso di azioni legalmente consentite, come la stampa o il download per uso personale e non commerciale. 2

3 Capitolo B5 IMPACT Il quinto ed ultimo inserto della collana Destinazione Europa - Boarding Pass per le Marie Curie Fellowship è dedicato all ultimo criterio di valutazione e capitolo di progettazione della proposta B5. Impact. Il proponente dovrà infine inserire un piano di attività di disseminazione denominato outreach rivolto al grande pubblico con l obiettivo di promuovere la consapevolezza dell importanza della Ricerca e Innovazione e diffondere la conoscenza delle Azioni Marie Curie. Le guide per i proponenti propongono una In questa sezione il ricercatore dovrà descrivere, entro il limite massimo di 4 pagine, l impatto della Marie Curie Fellowship sulla sua carriera professionale e sull Europa. Per quanto riguarda lo sviluppo della carriera del ricercatore, occorrerà approfondire quali sono le competenze che lista non esaustiva di possibili outreach activities che vengono riportate qui di seguito: Marie Curie Ambassador, Workshop Day, Summer-School Week, Marie Curie Project Open Day, Public talks, TV-Talks, podcasts and articles in Newspapers, e-newsletters, Multimedia releases. saranno acquisite/rafforzate attraverso il progetto. Quale impatto avranno queste competenze (scientifiche e trasversali) sulla futura carriera? Come il progetto contribuirà nel medio e lungo periodo allo sviluppo della carriera del ricercatore? In che modo le competenze acquisite/rafforzate miglioreranno le prospettive di carriera? A livello europeo invece il ricercatore dovrà evidenziare il suo contributo a rafforzare l eccellenza e la competitività europea. Come il progetto contribuirà all attrattività della ricerca europea? Il progetto porterà a creare nuove sinergie a livello intra-europeo? L Azione Marie Curie Intra-European Fellowships for Career Development (IEF) supporta la mobilità dei ricercatori in Europa e pertanto occorrerà dimostrare la genuinità di tale mobilità. Per mobilità genuina si intende che il ricercatore si sposta tra contesti geografici e lavorativi diversi da dove ha lavorato precedentemente. 3

4 Impact of competencies acquired during the fellowship on the future career prospects of the researcher, in particular through exposure to transferable skills training with special attention to exposure to the industry sector, where appropriate The project offers the potential for the fellow to acquire complementary competencies and to develop lasting collaborations Some of the claims with regards to the acquiring of new skills for the applicant are not well justified given the researcher's existing level of experience (e.g., management skills) The project will give the fellow opportunities to acquire complementary competencies and skills, which will help him to reach a position of scientific maturity The applicant provides some evidence of the impact of the project for their own academic career and some evidence of potential benefits to the host and wider European academic community The impact of competencies acquired during the fellowship on the future career prospects of the researcher is rather poorly described The impact of the acquisition of transferable/ complementary skills on the future research career prospects of the researcher has not been clearly outlined Contribution to career development, or re-establishment where relevant The contribution to career development or reestablishment is mentioned The ways in which the fellowship will contribute in the medium- and long-term to the development of the fellow s career were not discussed in sufficient detail The applicant s benefits from the fellowship are clearly described and are sound The proposal demonstrates that the competencies acquired will be important for the candidate s career development, and that the work proposed at the host institution are essential to this purpose Potential contribution of the proposed fellowship to the development of the applicant s career in the medium and long term is presented The relationship between the proposal and the future career plans of the applicant could have been outlined more clearly The contribution to a career development should be presented in more detail The proposal does not clearly identify the benefits of the research program on the short- or medium-term career path of the Researcher The proposal contains an exhaustive list of skills the candidate aims to obtain during the Fellowship 4

5 Benefit of the mobility to the European Research Area The mobility is considered as genuine, allowing the researcher to work in a different geographical environment The benefit of the mobility to the European research area is poor The mobility to the applicant's home country is genuine and beneficial to the European research area; it helps to attract back talented European researchers The proposal demonstrates that the competencies acquired will be important for the candidate s career development, and that the work proposed at the host institution are essential to this purpose The genuineness of the mobility is not evident The benefit of the mobility has been addressed mainly from the point of view of the applicant, rather than that of the European research area The concrete benefits of the mobility to the ERA are vaguely presented The mobility is genuine and would benefit the European Research Area by giving the Researcher a different working environment The information presented in the proposal does not provide sufficient grounds to justify the proposed mobility to the European research area. The applicant has already spent a considerable amount of time in the EU country hosting the fellowship Development of lasting cooperation and collaborations with other countries The project has excellent potential to produce stable and long term collaborations Opportunities for further collaborations have been missed There is potential for creating long term collaborations and mutually beneficial co-operation between host and the fellow The project will strengthen the collaboration between the present research institute of the applicant and the host institution and is a good starting point for further collaborative projects There is no information about how the existing links could be reinforced There is not sufficient information on future collaborations There is a probability that the project may lead to the development of lasting cooperation and collaborations with other countries 5

6 Contribution to European excellence and European competitiveness regarding the expected research results The project will have positive impacts on European excellence The proposal does not include concrete information about how the project can contribute to European excellence and competitiveness The contribution to European excellence is convincingly explained. The project contributes to the transfer of knowledge within the EU in a significant way Expected research results may contribute to an extent to European excellence The contribution to European excellence appears moderate with regard to the credibility of the project The contribution to European excellence and European competitiveness is not convincingly explained It does not appear from the proposal how significant will be the general contribution to European excellence and European competitiveness Impact of the proposed outreach activities A very good outreach plan has been proposed No outreach activities are proposed The planned outreach activities to the public and their feasibility are discussed in detail Project-related outreach activities are expected to have a positive impact The impact of outreach activities is limited. They are mainly addressed at students and are only partly related to the project itself Outreach activities relevant to a broad non-scientific audience are not described Some outreach activities are proposed but the description of the methods for their realization is very general and their success cannot be clearly measured Part of the proposed outreach activities are novel (the exhibition) but it is not measurable as the applicant does not give details on the organisation of this activity (where will it take place? for which type of public?) 6