SIMULAZIONE DELLA VALUTAZIONE DI ARTICOLI PUBBLICATI SU RIVISTE INDICIZZATE IN ISI WOS SECONDO I CRITERI DEFINITI DAI GRUPPI DI ESPERTI

Transcript

1 SIMULAZIONE DELLA VALUTAZIONE DI ARTICOLI PUBBLICATI SU RIVISTE INDICIZZATE IN ISI WOS SECONDO I CRITERI DEFINITI DAI GRUPPI DI ESPERTI DELLA VALUTAZIONE (GEV) DELL ANVUR: INTEGRAZIONE AL DOCUMENTO DEL 23 MARZO 2012 A cura del Gruppo di Lavoro di Ateneo Calcolo Soglie di Transizione per la VQR Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II Napoli 27 marzo 2012

2 Gruppo di Lavoro di Ateneo Calcolo Soglie di Transizione per la VQR Università degli Studi di Napoli Federico II Giovanni Miano, Coordinatore Comitato di Ateneo VQR Andreotti Amedeo Aria Massimo Asprone Domenico Bedini Emiliano Borbone Nicola Bracale Umberto Buccino Mariano Buttà Alessandro (Coinor) Capasso Raffaele Capozzoli Amedeo Cappabianca Paolo Cappelletti Piergiulio Carlomagno Chiara Catalanotti Bruno Cuocolo Davide D'Acierno Luca Dell'aversana Orabona Giovanni De Nardo Guglielmo De Stefano Sergio (Coinor) Di carlo Costantino Di Lorenzo Pierpaolo Di Natale Francesco Di Renzo Gianfranco Drago Francesco Esposito Elena Filippone Giovanni Fiore Gaetano Galdi Clemente Garufi Fabio Gentile Ivan Giannino Francesco Granata F. Paolo Imbriani Gianluca Izzo Giuseppe La Pietra Valeria Malapelle Umberto Manganelli Fiore Mangia Gianluigi Marinelli Luciana Melillo Rosa Marina Miele Erasmo Mele Cristina Molinaro Pasquale Monetti Valeria M. Montuori Paolo Moscato Vincenzo Napoli Raffaele Napolitano Giuliana Neglia Gianluca Nicotera Marco Valerio Paladino Simona Palella Boris Pasquariello Luigi (CSI) Passaro Fabiana Pepe Tiziana Raia Pasquale Riccitiello Francesco Ruvolo Antonio Saccà Francesco Santoro Massimo Scudiero Rosaria Segreto Sabrina Sepe Valentina Solari Domenico Tarallo Oreste Zampella Angela Zannini Mariastella (CNR) 2

3 In questa integrazione al documento del 23 marzo 2012 pubblichiamo le soglie di transizione tra le quattro classi 1, 2, 3, 4 sia per l Impact Factor (I R ), sia per il Numero di Citazioni (I C ) per le Subject Category di ISI WoS accorpate dai GEV 05 e 06. Le soglie per l indicatore I C sono state calcolate separatamente per le tipologie ISI article + letter e review. Disclaimer. Le soglie di transizione per l indicatore I C sono state stimate utilizzando il database di ISI WoS aggiornato al 26 marzo 2012 mentre i GEV, in accordo a quanto stabilito dal bando, restringeranno l analisi al 31 dicembre A causa di ciò le soglie riportate nella Sezione 1. potranno lievemente scostarsi da quelle che il CINECA calcolerà per conto dei GEV. Il Gruppo di Lavoro, inoltre, declina ogni responsabilità per eventuali errori materiali nella stima delle soglie di transizione. Per chiarimenti e ulteriori informazione rivolgersi a Giovanni Miano (miano@unina.it). 3 Studi di Napoli Federico II.

4 Subject Category Accorpate dal GEV 05 A1 PLANT SCIENCES; FORESTRY A2 ZOOLOGY; ORNITHOLOGY A3 ECOLOGY; BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION A4 MARINE & FRESHWATER BIOLOGY; FISHERIES; LIMNOLOGY; OCEANOGRAPHY A5 NEUROSCIENCES, NEUROIMAGING A6 MICROBIOLOGY; PARASITOLOGY; VIROLOGY; MYCOLOGY A7 INFECTIOUS DISEASES; TROPICAL MEDICINE A8 PSYCHOLOGY, MULTIDISCIPLINARY; PSYCHOLOGY, BIOLOGICAL A9 PHARMACOLOGY & PHARMACY; SUBSTANCE ABUSE A10 CELL & TISSUE ENGINEERING; MATERIALS SCIENCE; BIOMATERIALS; MEDICAL LABORATORY TECHNOLOGY; MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL A11 DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY; ANATOMY & MORPHOLOGY; MICROSCOPY; A12 BIOCHEMISTRY & MOLECULAR BIOLOGY; POLYMER SCIENCE; BIOPHYSICS A13 BIOCHEMICAL RESEARCH METHODS; MEDICAL INFORMATICS; MATHEMATICAL & COMPUTATIONAL BIOLOGY; CHEMISTRY, ANALYTICAL A14 CARDIAC & CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEMS; PERIPHERAL VASCULAR DISEASE 4 Studi di Napoli Federico II.

5 Subject Category Accorpate dal GEV 06 B1 ALLERGY; IMMUNOLOGY B2 ANDROLOGY; ENDOCRINOLOGY & METABOLISM B3 ANESTHESIOLOGY; CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE; EMERGENCY MEDICINE B4 CARDIAC & CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEMS; PERIPHERAL VASCULAR DISEASE B5 INFECTIOUS DISEASES; TROPICAL MEDICINE B6 HEMATOLOGY; RHEUMATOLOGY B7 GERIATRICS & GERONTOLOGY; MEDICINE, GENERAL & INTERNAL; PRIMARY HEALTH CARE; GERONTOLOGY (Social Science) B8 MEDICINE, LEGAL; CRIMINOLOGY & PENOLOGY (Social Science) B9 REHABILITATION; REHABILITATION (Social Science) B10 PUBLIC, ENVIRONMENTAL & OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH; ERGONOMICS (Social Science); PUBLIC, ENVIRONMENTAL & OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH (Social Science) B11 NURSING; NURSING (Social Science) B12 PSYCHIATRY; PSYCHIATRY (Social Science) B13 MICROBIOLOGY; VIROLOGY; PARASITOLOGY; MYCOLOGY B14 HEALTH CARE SCIENCES & SERVICES; HEALTH POLICY & SERVICES (Social Science) B15 NEUROSCIENCES; NEUROIMAGING B16 SUBSTANCE ABUSE; PHARMACOLOGY & PHARMACY B17 CELL & TISSUE ENGINEERING; MATERIALS SCIENCE, BIOMATERIALS; MEDICAL LABORATORY TECHNOLOGY; MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL B18 DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY; ANATOMY & MORPHOLOGY; MICROSCOPY B19 BIOCHEMISTRY & MOLECULAR BIOLOGY; BIOPHYSICS; POLYMER SCIENCE B20 BIOCHEMICAL RESEARCH METHODS; CHEMISTRY, ANALYTICAL; MATHEMATICAL & COMPUTATIONAL BIOLOGY; MEDICAL INFORMATICS 5 Studi di Napoli Federico II.

6 Subject Category FORESTRY + PLANT SCIENCES A1

7 Subject Category ORNITHOLOGY + ZOOLOGY A2

8 Subject Category BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION + ECOLOGY A3

9 Subject Category FISHERIES + LIMNOLOGY + MARINE & FRESHWATER BIOLOGY + OCEANOGRAPHY A4

10 Subject Category Neuroimaging + Neurosciences A5

11 Subject Category MICROBIOLOGY + MYCOLOGY + PARASITOLOGY + VIROLOGY A6

12 Subject Category INFECTIOUS DISEASES + TROPICAL MEDICINE A7

13 Subject PSYCHOLOGY, BIOLOGICAL (Social Sciences) + PSYCHOLOGY, MULTIDISCIPLINARY (Social Sciences) A8

14 Subject Category Pharmacology & Pharmacy + Substance of Abuse A9

15 Subject Category CELL & TISSUE ENGINEERING + MATERIALS SCIENCE, BIOMATERIALS + MEDICAL LABORATORY TECHNOLOGY + MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL Cell & Tissue Engineering è attiva dal A10

16 Subject Category ANATOMY & MORPHOLOGY + DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY + MICROSCOPY A11

17 Subject Category BIOCHEMISTRY & MOLECULAR BIOLOGY + BIOPHYSICS + POLYMER SCIENCE A12

18 Subject Category BIOCHEMICAL RESEARCH METHODS + CHEMISTRY ANALYTICAL + MATHEMATICAL & COMPUTATIONAL BIOLOGY + MEDICAL INFORMATICS Mathematical & Computational Biology è attiva dal A13

19 Subject Category CARDIAC & CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEMS + PERIPHERAL VASCULAR DISEASE A14

20 Subject Category ALLERGY + IMMUNOLOGY B 1

21 Subject Category ANDROLOGY + ENDOCRINOLOGY & METABOLISM B 2

22 Subject Category ANESTHESIOLOGY + CRITICAL CARE MEDICINE + EMERGENCY MEDICINE B 3

23 Subject Category CARDIAC & CARDIOVASCULAR SYSTEMS + PERIPHERAL VASCULAR DISEASE B 4

24 Subject Category INFECTIOUS DISEASES + TROPICAL MEDICINE B 5

25 Subject Category HEMATOLOGY + RHEUMATOLOGY B 6

26 Subject Category GERIATRICS & GERONTOLOGY + GERONTOLOGY (Social Science) + MEDICINE, GENERAL & INTERNAL ,327 1,25 0, ,489 1,329 1, ,847 1,558 1, ,925 1,652 1, ,276 1,943 1, ,654 1,516 1, ,684 1,589 1, B 7

27 Subject Category CRIMINOLOGY & PENOLOGY (Social Science) + MEDICINE, LEGAL ,561 1,047 0, ,561 0,94 0, ,488 1,094 1, ,643 1,042 0, ,49 1, ,69 1,28 1, ,694 1,159 0, B 8

28 Subject Category REHABILITATION + REHABILITATION (Social Science) ,155 0,982 0, ,447 1,011 0, ,643 1,183 1, ,602 1,205 0, ,884 1,224 1, ,995 1,375 1, ,995 1,375 1,1 Anno I C1 I C2 I C Anno I C1 I C2 I C B 9

29 Subject Category PUBLIC, ENVIRONMENTAL & OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH (Social Science) + PUBLIC, ENVIRONMENTAL & OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH + ERGONOMICS (Social Science) ,388 1,635 1, ,373 1,631 1, ,244 1,711 1, ,31 1,597 1, ,426 1,802 1, ,607 1,724 1, ,388 1,635 1, B 10

30 Subject Category NURSING + NURSING (Social Science) ,021 0,784 0, ,98 0,843 0, ,419 1,153 1, ,262 1,043 0, ,376 1,068 0, ,306 1,014 0, ,392 1,048 0, B 11

31 Subject Category PSYCHIATRY + PSYCHIATRY (Social Science) ,943 1,721 1, ,178 2,037 1, ,625 2,149 1, ,498 2,117 1, ,7 2,302 1, ,647 2,317 1, ,346 2,109 1, B 12

32 Subject Category MICROBIOLOGY + MYCOLOGY + PARASITOLOGY + VIROLOGY B 13

33 Subject Category HEALTH CARE SCIENCES & SERVICES + HEALTH POLICY SERVICES (Social Sciences) ,82 1,234 1, ,915 1,244 0, ,163 1,541 1, ,652 1,782 1, ,802 2,062 1, ,749 1,914 1, ,733 1,86 1, B 14

34 Subject Category Neuroimaging + Neurosciences B 15

35 Subject Category Pharmacology & Pharmacy + Substance of Abuse B 16

36 Subject Category CELL & TISSUE ENGINEERING + MATERIALS SCIENCE, BIOMATERIALS + MEDICAL LABORATORY TECHNOLOGY + MEDICINE, RESEARCH & EXPERIMENTAL Cell & Tissue Engineering è attiva dal B 17

37 Subject Category ANATOMY & MORPHOLOGY + DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY + MICROSCOPY B 18

38 Subject Category BIOCHEMISTRY & MOLECULAR BIOLOGY + BIOPHYSICS + POLYMER SCIENCE B 19

39 Subject Category BIOCHEMICAL RESEARCH METHODS + CHEMISTRY ANALYTICAL + MATHEMATICAL & COMPUTATIONAL BIOLOGY + MEDICAL INFORMATICS B 20