Informatica e diritto, Vol. XIV, 2005, n. 1-2, pp. 167-181

Informatica e diritto, Vol. XIV, 2005, n. 1-2, pp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`,EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE A @ CI & #`!,EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE =@ACK= A J JA? CE? A@ HC= E =JEL `! )??AII JA A =JE? `! )??AII @=F=HJA@A A= JHA= E EIJH= E E` " 5E?KHA =@AE@=JEA@AEIEIJA E@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E` # 2H IFAJJELAAGKAIJE E=FAHJAE =JAHE=@E@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A A FK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E 24- -55) AC EK JE E= E=>>E= =IIEIJEJ = =@EBBKIE A IA FHAFE?=FE = HA @A AJA? CEAE B H =JE?DAAJA A =JE?DA AC EKBBE?EFK>> E?EA AE FH?AIIE@E =L H @A A= E EIJH= E E 1 GKAIJ=FHE =B=IA@A FH?AI I @E@ECEJ= E = E A@A \= E A= E EIJH=JEL=I IJ=JEFHELE ACE=JE ILE KFF @A AE BH=IJHKJJKHA>=IAA =@EBBKIE A@A A? FAJA A IE B H =JE?DAJH=E FAHI = A ) ELA H =JEL IE E E E= A JAFH LLA@KJ =@EI?EF E =HAI =?K EAIFA?EBE?EIJHK A JEA@EIJEJKJEBEH =@ECEJ= A FH J? E B H = JE? F IJ=A AJJH E?=?AHJEBE?=J=E @EIFA I=>E EFAH? IA JEHA \KI @A \E B H =JE?=@=F=HJA@A A= E EIJH= E E A HEIFAJJ @A A A?AII=HEA C=H= EA@E=KJA JE?EJ A@=BBE@=>E EJ =CAL AHE AL=HA? A E GKAIJ= \=KJ HA =LL?=J E 2 JA = 4 * 4475 + FKJAHA,EHEJJ 11 E = /EKBBH '&& F "#

$& 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A B=IA \E JH @K E A@A A K LAJA? CEAIEIE= E EJ=J== = AH=HEFH @K E A@EFH?AIIEA @A E>KH?H=JE?ECE AIEIJA JE 6= A=FFH??E @E?KED=HEIA JEJ =?DA =FH @K E A H =JEL= D= E EJ=J B HJA A JAE>A ABE?E? IACKE>E E? \KI @A \E B H =JE?=E JAH E E@EABBE?=?E=A@ABBE?EA =@A \= E A= E EIJH=JEL= 5 A > A =JE?DA I JJ GKAIJ FH BE ALE?A @A@A ]@?K A J ^ \= E A= E EIJH=JEL= IJ=J=@=IA FHAE FAH E=J=IK??AJJ @E @?K A J E JAI? ALAH AFH FHE >=HE?A JH @A \AIAH?E E @AEFK> > E?EF JAHEABK?H @AEH=FF HJEJH== E EIJH= E AAFHEL=JE =FHE = B=IA@E@ECEJ= E = E A@A =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A D== JAH=J E HK B @= A J= A@A @?K A J?DA IAFFKHA A =IK=B H =]E B H =JE?=^ D=? IAHL=J E KJ=J= =FH FHE=?A JH= EJ =?DA H =JEL= 1, 2 4 &@E?A >HA ""#6AIJ K E? @A A@EIF IE E E ACEI = JELAAHAC = A J=HEE =JAHE=@E@?K A J= E A= E EIJH=JEL= A @EI?EF E =HAE IEIJA =E B H =JE? @ECAIJE A@A FH J? A@AEFH?A@E A JE= E EIJH=JELE B=HEBAHE A J AI? KIEL= A JA=E]B KIIE@?K A J= E^ 6= AE F IJ= E AD= BBAHJ E BE=? = A?HEJE?DA@E?DEHEJA A L=?DAE GKAIJ @ IEIBHKJJ=IIAH =FFEA AF JA E= EJ BBAHJA @= A K LAJA? CEAE GK= J?E?DA A = @= EJ JH=@E E = A FH= JE? AH= E = A E GKA =E B H =JE?=FK HEIK J=HAB=HH=CE I IA =@@EHEJJKH=EHH= E = A! 5E IIAHL=J E B=JJE? A \KI @A A K LAJA? CEAF JAIIAH=F FHAIA J=HAK B=JJ HA@EH= E = E = E A@A \=JJELEJ = E EIJH=JEL=? JAL E>A ABE?EE JAH E E@EABBE?EA =AJH=IF=HA = LAIEB IIAF IJ= =?A JH @A IEIJA = \]E B H = E A@ECEJ= A^ A FE E @?K A J IA>>A AE B H =JE? 5E GKE @E=FAHJ=K = K L=B=IA@A FH?A@E A J @EE B H =JE = E A@A =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A " E FH J=J= 2=H = E FH F IEJ @EK LAH AFH FHE ]FHE?EFE @E@?K A J= EJ ^ @A IJH @EHEJ J. +)4) ) ),?K A J= E AA@?K A J L?A @EH = E -? CEKH L :1 4 = 6HA??= E '&' F! 1 GKAIJ IA I * *)4,- 1 1 B H =JE?= A C LAH A J AILE KFF I IJA E>E A E 4EL EJ @EH FK>>? # FF ''II - *- 15)41 2H J? E B H =JE? =KJ = E A@EK HACEIJH FHE F=II LAHI E FH?A@E A J = E EIJH=JEL A AJJH E? E 3K=@AH E@E6A A KI = =74 DJJF MMM JA A KI EJ E@A= IJH= FDF FE@ $FE@=HA=! " =@EIJE E A@A FH?AII @E@ECEJ= E = E A@A =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E AE @KAB=IE

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E $' = =E JAH FAH=>E EJ JH= A= E EIJH= E E = =HAE CAC AHE = E A@AE FH?AIIEA@= =ABBAJJEL=JH= IE E ALAHI @= EJ @EAH C= E A@AEIAH LE E E A =?EJJ=@E EAE FHAIA ) ELA H =JEL?E F=II= A?AII=HE= A JAFAH =FHAI=@\=JJ @A =?HEIE@A @?K A J A =? I=?H= E A@A HK @A @=J = BE A@E JJE E =HA AHA = E EE JAH AA@AIJAH A@A A= E EIJH= E EA EC E H=HA \AH C= E A@EIAHLE E E A =?EJJ=@E EAE FHAIA 1 GKAIJ GK=@H IE??=E + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A@ CI % =H # &?DA FAH =FHE =L J= =BBAH =E @ E?EIEL =??= J = @?K A J E HK @A @=J GK= AFHAIKFF IJ E @ABAJJE>E AFAH =? FEKJ=@ECEJ= E = E A@A \= E A= E EIJH=JEL= 6H L=@K GKA? FE A J E FH?AI I @EI =JAHE= E = E A@AEB KIIEE B H =JELEALEA AL= HE =J \A H AF=JHE E @EE B H = E EH=?? JAAFH @ JJA@= A= E EIJH= E E \E B H = E A@ELA J= E B=JJE =?DE=LA@EL J=@EK IEIJA == E EIJH=JEL?DA FKHFHAIAHL= @ A A?AII=HEAAIECA A@E?AHJA =A@ =KJA JE?EJ CK=H@==E@=JE? JA KJE AEHACEIJHEA AC E=H?DELEFK>> E?E? A=@K =IJH= H@E =HE=HEI HI= I A \ JJE?=@E=IIE?KH=HA =JH= IF=HA = AE? BH JE@AC E= E EIJH=JE ==?DA=EBE E@EK EC E H= A J @A \ABBE?EA =A@A \ABBE?=?E=@A \= E A@AEFK>> E?EF JAHE 1 F HJ= JA I JJ GKAIJ FH BE =@ABE E E A? JA KJ== \=HJ AJJ @A + @E?A E >=IA= GK= AFAH@=J @EK =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A@ALAE JA @AHIE]E @=J B H =J? K GKAJH=JJ=J @=K =FK> > E?== E EIJH= E A^ IEJH=JJ=@EK =@ABE E E AL KJ= A JA= FE=?DAHE? FHA @A I E@=JEFH @ JJE@EHAJJ= A JA@= \= E EIJH= E A ==?DAGKA EB H =JE@== JHEI CCAJJEA? K GKAJH=JJ=JEA? IAHL=JE@= =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A 1 @=J @ECEJ= A? I E JAI @ELEA A = F=HE@AC E=JJEA@AE@?K A JE ]E B H = E AFHE =HE=A@ HECE = A@=?KE F IIE>E AABBAJJK=HA IK@ELAH FAH=J=@= =,EHAJJEL=A = =J=@= E EIJH FAH \E L= E AA AJA? CEAE @=J="CA =E #E / 7 BA>>H=E #!#? JA A JA A E AACKE@=E =JAHE=@E@ECEJ= E = E A@A \= E EIJH= E A =JH= IE E AJH= =FHE =A =IA? @=B=IA AC=J=ANFHAI IEILAH>EI = \=@ E A@E@KAFH LLA@E A JE H =JELE@ECH= @AHE AL= = E @A?HAJ IK 5EIJA =2K>> E? @E+ AJJELEJ @ CI &BA>>H=E # " AE + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A@ CI % =H # & A AE JA E E@A / LAH =IA? @=B=IA@A = @ECEJ= E = E A@ LHA>>AJH L=HAE GKAIJAHEB H AK FE?DA=@ACK=J IKFF HJ H =JEL

% 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A IEJEFE@EIKFF HJ HEFH @K E EA? FEAFAHC EKIE? IA JEJE@= = ACCA^ =HJ? @ CI & # + A J E B=JJE E + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= AFHALA@A?DA A= E EIJH= E E@A>>= KJE E =HA A JA? CEA@A \E B H = E AA@A =? K E?= E A A =CAIJE A@AEFH?A@E A JE A= E EIJH= E EF II H=?? C EAHAC E=JJE E@?K A JEAE @=JE@=?DEK GKAB H =JE@EK @AJAH E =J FH?A@E A J E K LAH A FH FHE ]B=I?E? E B H =JE? ^ =HJ "? @ CI & # =JKH= A JA FHALEIJ?DA A =? K E?= E A@E=LLE @A FH?A@E A J =EIA IE@A \=HJ &@A = ACCA%=C IJ '' " @ LH AIIAHA? JA KJ= A E A@A A @= EJ FAHAIAH?EJ=HAE LE=JA A =JE?=E@EHEJJE @E?KE= \=HJ @A = ACCA " ''FHA @AHALEIE A@AC E=JJE@A FH?A@E A J AFHAIA J=HA A HEAI?HEJJAA@?K A JE= \= E EIJH= E A,152 1*1 16,-1,)61 -, /5 & # 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A IE E EJ==F HHA \E B H = E A@ECEJ= A=?A JH @A FH?A@E A J = E EIJH=JEL A AJJH E? = L= JHABE =@=BBAH =HAK LAH AFH FHE ]FHE?EFE @E@EIF E>E EJ ^ @AE@=JEFK>> E?EA K?E=J = \=HJ? @ CI & # A@A? E =J @= \=HJ #? @A IJAII @A?HAJ 2AH]@EIF E>E EJ ^ I\E JA @A] = F IIE>E EJ @E=??A@AHA=E@=JEIA =HAIJHE E E HE? @K?E>E E=AIF E?E JA H A@E ACCA^ =HJ AJJ @ CI & # =F HJ=J=E L=JE L=@EGKAIJ FHE?EFE HEIEA@A A \=BBAH =HA?DA?E=I?K == E EIJH= E A@ALAHA @AHA@EIF E>E EE@=JE@E?KE JEJ =HA]E @= EJ @ECEJ= A^ =HJ? @ CI & #=FHEL=JEA=@= JHA= E EIJH= E E 2AH=IIE?KH=HA \ABBAJJELEJ @EGKAIJ=@EIF IE E AE + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= AD=F IJ K LAH AFH FHE >> EC FAH A= E E IJH= E E@E=JJEL=HIE= ELA JA? CE? A@ HC= E =JEL # =@EIF E>E EJ @A @=J E B H =J @ECEJ= AFHAIKFF A E B=JJE?DA IJAII @=J IE=B H =J H=?? J? IAHL=J AHAI @EIF E>E AA@=??AI IE>E A]? \KI @A AJA? CEA@A \E B H = E AA@A =? K E?= E A^ =HJ #? @ CI & #?DA? IA J= =BHKE E AAHEKJE # \=HJ? @ CI & # FHALA@A E B=JJE?DA A= E EIJH= E E]IE HC= E = A@=CEI? =J= ABE AKJE E = @? A @= EJ FE =FFH FHE=JA^ A K LAJA? CEA

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E % E = E A@=F=HJA@E?EJJ=@E E E FHAIAA@= JHEKBBE?EFK>> E?E E F HJ= JAFHA?EI=HA \= >EJ @E=FF E?= E A@EGKAIJ=@EIF IE E A 1 FHE?EFE @E@EIF E>E EJ D=F HJ=J=CA AH= AIE=I JJ E FH BE CCAJJEL $ IE=I JJ GKA I CCAJJEL %,EIF E>E EJ IEC EBE?=FAH =KJ =JE?=? @ELEIE A@EJKJJA A E B H = E E =??AII E @EI?HE E =J = AIJAIIA 1 E EJE= =? I?E>E E J @AE@=JEHE = C GKA EFHALEIJE@= A ACCEA@=EHAC = A JEIE=FAHE FHEL=JE=@AI E EJEA@AI? KIE EE =JAHE=@E=??AII IE=FAH A= JHA = E EIJH= E E?DAF II =??A@AHAI =E@=JE A?AII=HEFAH IL CE A J @A =FH FHE==JJELEJ EIJEJK E = A 7 JAHE HA E EJA H=FFHAIA J=J @= A?AII=HE HEIFAJJ @A = H =JE L=E =JAHE=@EHEIAHL=JA =@AE@=JEFAHI = E & 1 HE?DE= = = H =JE L=E JA =@EFHEL=?O IE?KH= A JAE @E?=JEL @A AE JA E E@A ACEI = J HA@EALEJ=HA?DA \=??AII JA A =JE? HA?DE? I EHEI?DE@E? I?A = @AE@=JE=?DA=I CCAJJE =KJ HE =JE )FF=HAF EALE@A JA =L J @EALEJ=HA?DA \E JAH? AIIE AF II=? IA JEHA? JH EE @EI?HE E =JE IKE?EJJ=@E E =IIE?KH= @?DAEJH=JJ= A JE@E@=JEFAHI = EE = >EJ FK> > E? =LLA C= AI? KIEL= A JA A \= >EJ @A? @ ]FHE?EFE @EBE = EJ ^ =HJ & @ CI '$! ' =F HJ=J=CA AH= EIIE =@A FHE?EFE @E@EIF E>E EJ =? H= EJEC= J=@==?K AJ=II=JELAA??A E EFHALEIJA@= \=HJ? $ @ CI & # AHA =JELA= \AIAH?E E @A A=JJELEJ ABK E E@E H@E AA@EIE?K HA =FK>> E?= @EBAI=AIE?KHA = = E = AA? IK J= E EA AJJ H= E $ + AFHA?A@A JA A JAHE AL=J IKFH= =@ABE E E A@E@=J @EK =FK>> E?= = E EIJH= E AB H EJ=@= \=HJ AJJ @A + @E?A JHA @ = FE= J= J @=HE? FHA @AHAJKJJA AE B H = E EJH=JJ=JA@=C EKBBE?EFK>> E?E % 1 >=IA= \=HJ? @ CI & # I JA KJA=@=IIE?KH=HA =@EIF E>E EJ A BHKE>E EJ @AEFH FHE@=JE] 5J=J A4ACE EA A=KJ EA?= E^ F EFHALEIJ?DA A @EIF IE E E??AH A JE \=??AII =E@?K A JEE B H =JE?EA =BHKE>E EJ @A AE B H = E E @ECEJ= EIE=FF E?DE =?DA=ECAIJ HE@EIAHLE EFK>> E?EA@=C E HC= EI E@E@EHEJJ FK>> E? =HJ? " @ CI & # &, CI!CEKC! '$ + @E?AE =JAHE=@EFH JA E A@AE@=JEFAHI = E ' 1 >=IA=GKAIJ=@EIF IE E A]GK= K GKAJH=JJ= A J @E@=JEFAHI = E@=F=HJA@E I CCAJJEFK>> E?E? IA JEJ I J= J FAH IL CE A J @A ABK E EEIJEJK E = E^ A \ABBAJJK=HAGKAIJEJH=JJ= A JE A= E EIJH= E E@ LH= IA FHA IIAHL=HAEFHAIKF F IJEAE E EJEF IJE@= @ CI '$! /E L=HE? H@=HAE GKAIJ=IA@A?DAE >=IA

% 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A 7?A F=HJE? =HA AHEJ= E LA?A E HEBAHE A J ABBAJJK=J @= \=HJ #? @ CI & # = = H =JEL=? K EJ=HE=E =JAHE=@EHEKJE E @A AE B H = E E@A IAJJ HAFK>> E?,EHAJJEL=! '& +- @A % LA >HA! = H =JEL=? K EJ=HE=HE?DE= =J=E JH @K?AK EIJEJKJ BE H=I? I?EKJ = IJH H@E = A J E HEKJE E @A AE B H = E E@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E 1 ACEI =J HA? K EJ=HE F=H JA @ @= =? IJ=J= E A?DAE@=JEFH @ JJEA@AJA KJE@= AFK>> E?DA = E EIJH= E EI K =FHA E I=ABE H=I JJ L= KJ=J=HEI HI=FAH =?HAI?EJ=A? E?=A =?HA= E A@EF IJE@E =L H AE? H=CCE=E HEKJE E 2AHHEKJE E I\E JA @A] \KI @E@?K A JEE F IIAII @EA JE FK>> E?E@=F=HJA@EFAHI ABEIE?DA CEKHE@E?DA=BE E? AH?E= E? AH?E= E@ELAHIE@= I? F E E E= A A \= >EJ @AE? FEJE@EIAHLE E FK>> E? FAHEGK= EE@?K A JEI IJ=JEFH @ JJE I?= >E @E @?K A JEJH=A JEFK>> E?EAI? KIEL= A JAE =@A FE A J @AE H? FEJE@EIAHLE E FK>> E?? IJEJKEI?AHEKJE E ^ =HJ ",EHAJJEL=?EJ =IJAII= H =JEL=? K EJ=HE=HAC = @= EJ?HEJAHEA FHE? FE@A HEKJE E ->>A A E HE?DE= FAH=J @= \=HJ #@A + @E?A= =@EHAJJEL=? K EJ=HE= E F HJ= JAFAHK @KF E?A H@E A@EH=CE E =IFA?EBE?= \=??A E A??KE A + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A KJE E =J E JAH E A ]HEKJE E ^ >?DE=HEI?A?DA A H A? K EJ=HEAE =JAHE=@EHEKJE E JH L= =FF E?= E A E?=I @EAIAH?E E @A @EHEJJ @E=??AII =E IA IE@A = ACCA " '' E?=I @E=??AII =E@=JE FAH=J @== JH= FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A A \AIAH?E E @A =FH FHE==JJELEJ EIJEJK E = A = \=HJ "!?, 2 4 ""# \=??AII =?DAJA A =JE? @=F=HJA@EK \= E EI JH= E A=@=H?DELE@E= JH== E EIJH= E A FAH=??AHJ= A JE@EKBBE?E FAHE? JH @A A @E?DE=H= E EI IJEJKJELAFHAIA J=JA@=E?EJJ=@E E IE? IE@AH= FAH=J FAHBE = EJ @EHE AL= JA E JAHAIIAFK>> E? =EIA IE@AC E=HJJ II @ CI '$! +BH + IE@AH= @ #@A =,EHAJJEL=! '& +- =IJAII= H =JEL=? K EJ=HE=FHALA@A?DA] I?= >E @E@?K A JEJH=A JEFK> > E?EAI? KIEL= A JAE =@A FE A J @AE H? FEJE@EIAHLE E FK>> E?? IJEJKEI?A HEKJE E ^ =HJ ",EHAJJEL=! '& +-

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E %!!,152 1*1 16,-1,)61 ),-/7) - 6 6-+ /1+ -, 4/) 1 )618 )IIE?KH=HA =@EIF E>E EJ @EJKJJEEFH FHE@=JE]E @= EJ @ECEJ= A^ IEC EBE?=?DA A= E EIJH= E E@AL A?AII=HE= A JA=JJEL=HIEIE== ELA JA? CE??DA HC= E =JEL 1 FHE K C >> EC=J HE= A JAHE?DEAIJ \KJE E @A AJA? CEAE B H =JE?DABE @= =?HA= E A =?GKEIE E A@A \E B H = E A 1 @=J @ALAF EAIIAHA=H?DELE=J A? IAHL=J IA FHA? E A@AIE EIJHK A JE 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A@ GKE @E K L A@A?EIE L E FK I = A= E EIJH= E E A =@EHA E A@EK =FEA ==JJK= E A @A = H =JEL=LECA JAE =JAHE=@EFH J? E B H =JE? ACAIJE A E B H =JE =J=@AEFH?A@E A JE= E EIJH=JELE 1 B=JJEL=HE AL=J?DA IJ= JA =@EI?EF E =E = E?EJ=J= I =? H==II=EF? @EBBKIEE IEIJA EE B H =JE =JE@ECAIJE A@AEB KIIEE B H =JELE + AIE @AJJ E B=JJE BE H=IE FAH=J=J KJ? KHJ \E B H =JE = E A@AEFH?AIIEAIE IJA JE?DA A =CH= F=HJA@AE?=IE? IEIJEJ= A = AH==KJ = E A @AEHACEIJHEA@=H?DELE?=HJ=?AE = H =JEL=IK FH J? E B H =JE? E LA?A FHALA@A I \E B H =JE = E A@AEHACEIJHE ==?DA @= EJ AHAGKEIEJEFAH=CAL =HA K \=H?DELE= E AAJH=I EIIE A@AEB KIIE@?K A J= E 5 E @K>>EA A E F E?= E E@E?=H=JJAHA HC= E =JEL FAH? C EAHA=FFEA EL= J=CCE @A =@ECEJ= E = E A E B=JJE A?AII=HE?DA A= E EIJH= E EE E E = FH K LAHAK =I IJ= E= AHALEIE A@AEFH?A@E A JE= E EIJH=JELE! )??AII JA A =JE? + AFHA?A@A JA A JA=??A =J \=BBAH = E A@A FHE?EFE @E @EIF E>E EJ FAHIACKAE = EJKJJ E BE A@E EC E H=HA =JH=IF=HA =@A \= E A= E EIJH=JEL= =JJH=LAHI \KI @EJA? CEA?DAHA @= @=LLA H ABBAJJEL E @EHEJJ @E=??AII @AE?EJJ=@E E= IJ=J @AEFH?A@E A JE?KE I E JAHAII=JE +BH, 2 4 &@E?A >HA ""# 6AIJ 7 E? @A A@EIF IE E E ACEI =JELAAHAC = A J=HEE =JAHE=@E@?K A J= E A= E EIJH=JEL= A, 2 +! JJ >HA 4AC AJA? E?DAFAHE FH J? E B H =JE? @E?KE= @A?HAJ @A 2HAIE@A JA@A = 4AFK>> E?= JJ >HA''& " &

%" 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A + A J E B=JJE =EIA IE@A = ACCA " ''! E@=JEAE@?K A JEFH @ JJE@= \= E EIJH= E A@A>> F JAHAIIAHA? IK J=JEFAH \AIAH?E E @A @EHEJJ @\=??AII = BE A@A =JKJA =@A AIEJK= E E CEKHE@E?= A JAHE AL= JE \=??AII? @ JA A =JE? " =C E=JJE= E EIJH=JELEAH=CE FHALEIJ @= \=HJ #'@A, 2 4 ""# = E EJ=J= A JA= AE B H = E E@A IEIJA =E B H =JE? @EFH J? A@ECAIJE AE B H =JE?=@AE@?K A JE 1 LEHJ @A FHE?EFE @E@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JEFK>> E?E \EIJEJKJ @A @EHEJJ @E=??AII =?GKEIJ= K L LEC HA@ LA @ A= E EIJH= E E=IIE?KH=HA \ABBAJJELEJ @EJ= A@EIF E>E EJ # \=??AII JA A =JE? AIFHAII= A JAHE? I?EKJ @= \=HJ # @A + @E?A K CE@= \AIIAHAK K L @EHEJJ H=FFHAIA J=E LA?AK = AH= @= EJ @EAIAH?E E @A @EHEJJ @E?KE=C E=HJJ AII ACCA " '' ) F IJ @A \E CHAII AC EKBBE?EA AC E=H?DELE?=HJ=?AE @A \) E EIJH= E A LE E? AC= A J JA A =JE? =C E=H?DELEA= A >=?DA@=JE@A =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A? C EE @K>>EL= J=CCE?DA A @AH AJA? E?DA@E? IK J= E AA@E JAHH C= E A? IA J =JKH= A JA A HEIFAJJ @A = H =JEL=E =JAHE=@EHEIAHL=JA =@AE @=JEFAHI = EIKFH= \E JAHAII=J @ LH AIIAHA AII E? @E E A @E? IK J=HA AGKE @E? I?AHA I AE B H = E E =?KE? I?A = IE= A?AII=HE=FAH =?KH=@AEFH FHEE JAHAIIEGK= EBE?=JE 1 JHA? AFAH \AH C= E A@EJKJJEEIAHLE EE HAJA=FHEL=JE A = E EIJH= E E@ LH= FHALA@AHA \KI @AEFE E@ AEA@ FF HJK E! 1 +=F 8@A = ACCA @A@E?=J = \EIJEJKJ @A \=??AII =E@?K A JE= E EIJH=JELE " 2AH=??AII JA A =JE? I\E JA @A =? IK J= E A FAHLE=JA A =JE?= @AC E=H?DELEA@AE @?K A JEE B H =JE?E@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E EIE=FAH =JKJA =@EIEJK= E ECEKHE@E?= A JAHE AL= JE@=F=HJA@E?DE A=>>E=E JAHAIIA IE=FAH A=JJELEJ = E EIJH=JELA=HJ,A E>AH= E A)12) @A! LA >HA # 3K= J = \ CCAJJ @A \=??AII IEHE AL=? AAII IEAIJA @=BE =HE? FHA @AHA C EE B H = E AJH=JJ=J=@=K =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A IE HEJA KJ?DALEHEA JHE I E@=JEAE@?K A JE A?KE@ABE E E E H =JELAI JHA @ = FEA ==?DA AHACEIJH= E E@AC E=??AIIE=EIEIJA EE B H =JE?E FK>> E?EE GKAIJ IA I + I /EKIJ ) 5E? IA CEKHEI@E ' LA >HA''' $! # 8=HE? H@=J E B=JJE?DA F II AIIAHAE L?=JA@EBBE? J HC= E =JELAFAH E FA@EHA @EBBAHEHA \=??AII @=F=HJA@A \E JAHAII=J + I 5J IA 81 # =CCE ''& $!#

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E %# IJHK A JE@EE@A JEBE?= E A? A =?=HJ=@EE@A JEJ A AJJH E?=A =?=HJ= = E = A@AEIAHLE E =EIA IE@A \=HJ $"? EA @A + @E?A 5EHA @AH= FAHJ= J A?AII=HEA @EBE?DA=EHAC = A JE?DA@EI?E F E = \AIAH?E E @A @EHEJJ @E=??AII FHALEIJ E JHA?DAJ= EHAC = A JEIE= FK>> E?=JEIK]IEJEFK>> E?E=??AIIE>E EFAHLE=JA A =JE?=^ =HJ # @ CI & #! )??AII @=F=HJA@A A= JHA= E EIJH= E E =F HJ=J=E L=JEL=@A FHE?EFE @E@EIF E>E EJ HEIEA@A A \=BBAH =HA?DA \=??AII =E@=JE@A A= E EIJH= E E C=H= JEJ =JKJJEC E= JHE I CCAJJEFK>> E?E JHA?DA=EFHEL=JE =EIA IE@A = ACCA " '' E B=JJEFHALEIJ?DAGK= K GKA@=J JH=JJ=J @=K =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A@A>>=AIIAHA]HAI =??AIIE>E AABHKE>E A= A= JHA= E EIJH= E EGK= @ \KJE E = E A@A @=J IE= A?AII=HE=FAH IL CE A J @AE? FEJEEIJEJK E = E@A \= E EIJH= E AHE?DEA@A JA^ =HJ #? @ CI & # 6= A@EIF IE E A@ LHA>>AH=FFHAIA J=HAK E F HJ= JA B=JJ HA@EH= E = E = E A@A \=JJELEJ = E EIJH=JEL= A AE JA E E @A ACEI =J HAJ= A H = E B=JJE @ LHA>>A JJE E =HAEB KIIEE B H =JE LEE K =HA= J GKA =@A A= E EIJH= E E?=H=JJAHE =J=@=CH=LE@EBAJ JE@E? K E?= E E IA FH FHE @= \E? K E?=>E EJ /E \=HJ $?, 2 4 ""# FHALA@AL= =F IIE>E EJ @E=??AI I = IEIJA =@ECAIJE A@AEB KIIE@?K A J= E@E= JHAFK>> E?== E E IJH= E A =E + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= AIEIFE CABE =F HHA E?=F =@ C E= E EIJH= E AK LAH AFH FHE @EHEJJ @E=??AII JA A =JE? =E@=JE@AC E= JHEKBBE?EFK>> E?E $ )BH JA@EGKAIJ @EHEJJ? H HEIF @AK LAH AFH FHE >> EC @=F=HJA@A A= E EIJH= E E@E=JJE L=HIEFAH? IA JEHAJ= A=??AII \=HJ #?! @A + @E?AFHALA@AE B=JJE?DA \= E EIJH= E AJEJ =HA@AE@=JE]FHA@EIF A CAIJEI?AA@AH C=^ EIAHLE EE B H =JE?E = \K F A?AII=HE $ +DA I?DA =IE=GKA JH=??E=J @= +=F 8@A = ACCA " '' @E IJH=J @= B=JJ?DA IK =>=IA@A HE LE? FEKJ @= \=HJ #? @ CI & # FAH= =?DAFAH \=??AII =E@=JEABBAJJK=J @= A= E EIJH= E E AAI? KIE E FAH=JA@= \=HJ " @A = ACCA " ''? I? A @EBE?=J @= = ACCABA>>H=E # #

%$ 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A 5 JJ GKAIJ FH BE @ALAHE AL=HIE? AFHAIKFF IJE A?AII=HEFAH \=??AII IE= \E JAH? AIIE AJH= AHAJE@AEL=HEA JEA \E JAH FAH=>E EJ 3K= J = FHE =IFAJJ IEHE AL=?DAEB KIIEE B H =JELEJH= A= E EIJH= E ED= H =EJH L=J K =? H E?AJA? E?= A 5EIJA =2K>> E? @E+ AJJELEJ 52+ @EI?EF E =J @= @ CI &BA>>H=E # " 2AHC=H= JEHA \E JAH FAH=>E EJ IEHA @AE LA?A A?AII=HE \KI @EIJ= @=H@? K E@=F=HJA@A A= E EIJH= E E 1 @EBAJJ @EFHALEIE E? JA KJA A + @E?A IEHEJA C =FF E?=>E E A H ACE LECA JE@AJJ=JAE =JAHE=@EFH J? E B H =JE? ACAIJE A@AEB KIIE@?K A J= E A= E EIJH= E E@ LH= E = EJKJJ? IAHL=HAE@=JEIA? @ @= EJ CA AA E F=HJE? =HA E >=IA= \=HJ $@A, 2 +! JJ >HA?E=I?K == E EIJH= E A@ALAC=H= JEHA = ACCE>E EJ A JA F @AEFH FHE@=JE=@ JJ= @ EB H =JEFHALEIJE@= \=HJ $? AJJ > @A = @A E>AH=)12) " ''& % LLAH = JHEB H =JE FH FHEAJ=HE A = E EIJH= E E@ LH= E JHAJA AHFHAIA JA?DA? AFHALEIJ @= \=HJ "@A =@A E>AH= E A)12) # EB H =JEFHAI?A JE@ LH= IA FHAC=H= JEHA = = ACCE>E EJ \E JAH FAH=>E EJ A \E JAHI?= >E @AE @?K A JE > = = JAH=>E EJ @A @?K A J @A @=J @KH= JA AB=IE @E=??AII A? IAHL= E A? =F IIE>E EJ @EABBAJJK=HA FAH= E E@E HE?AH?=JH= EJAE @E?E@E? =IIEBE?= E A @E=H?DELE= E A?D IKE? JA KJE@AE@?K A JE @ \E KJ=>E EJ A JA F @A? JA KJ A@A = IK=IJHKJJKH= 1H=FF HJEJH== E EIJH= E A?A@A JAAHE?DEA@A JAF JH= AIIAHA @EI?EF E =JE@==FF IEJA? LA E E=EIA IE@A \=HJ #&? @ CI & # E?KE@ LH= AIIAHAE @E?=JA =@AIA FE A? @E E EA@E E EJE= \=??AII F IJE=JKJA =@A =HEIAHL=JA =@AE@=JEFAHI = E 1 + @E?A FAH @AJJ=@KAE F HJ= JEIIE EFHE? FE 1 FHE K C IE IJ=>E EI?A?DA]E JH=IBAHE A J @EK @=J @=K IEIJA =E B H =JEL =@ K = JH @EBE?= =JEJ =HEJ @A @=J ^ =HJ #&? @ CI & # E F HJ= JAHE AL=HA E JHA? AE ACEI =J HAIEIE=??KF= % 5A? @ J= A@EIF IE E A]E@?K A JEB H =JE@EHAJJ= A JAIKIKFF HJ E B H =JE? F II AIIAHAJH=IBAHEJEIK IKFF HJ @E A HE = E A IA =F=II=CCE IKIKFF HJ?=HJ=?A E K B H =J? B H A= IJ= @=H@5/ FFKHAE K @AEIACKA JEB H =JE 2,. ).2 A AJ=? @A^

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E %% J =?DA@AE? IJE@A \=??AII. HJK =J= A JA= \ HECE =HE=B H K = E AE >=IA= =GK= AE? IJE@A \=??AII = @=L= E JAH= A JA=?=HE? @A \= E EIJH= E AHE?DEA@A JA =B H K = E A@ABE EJEL=@A =FHALE IE A H =JEL==HJ #? @ CI & #=BBAH =?DA \=??AII @ALA=LLA EHAIA = AHE I= L I E HE? I?E A J @EALA JK= E]? IJE A??A E = E^ 5E GKE @EALEJ=J @EF HHAK @EIE?A JEL = \=??AII C=H= JA @ =?DA \ FF HJK? H@E = A J? =@EIF IE E A? JA KJ== \=HJ "!, 2 4 ""#?DAFHALA@A?DA] A= E EIJH= E E?AHJEBE?= JEI JA KJA=? IA JEHA= A= E EIJH= E EFH?A@A JE IA = AHE =? IK J= E AFAHLE=JA A =JE?=@AE H =H?DELEE B H = JE?E^ " 51+74- ),-1,)61 -,-1 5156-1,- - 27** 1+0- ) 1 1564) 1 1 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A IE??KF=I J= J @E=IIE?KH=HA?DAJKJJEEI CCAJJE?DA AD= @EHEJJ F II= =??A@AHA=E@=JE @A A= E EIJH= E E /H= @A=JJA E A HEIAHL=J==?DA= JA =@A = IE?KHA =@AE@=JEIJAIIE 1 FH > A =@A =IE?KHA = K @AEC= C EFHE?EF= E@EJKJJEEIEIJA E E B H =JELE = IAF IIE>E A =? H=FE E F HJ= JA A IAJJ HAFK>> E? AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E A \AIAH?E E @A =FH FHE==JJELEJ EIJE JK E = AH=?? C FH @K? A@=H?DELE= K \A H AGK= JEJ @E @=JEA@?K A JE 1 >=IA= A H ABE GKEAI= E =JA JKJJAGKAIJAE B H = E E@ LH= AIIAHAHAIA@EIF E>E E]E @= EJ @ECEJ= A^ 3KAIJ IEC EBE?=?DAE@=JE@ LH= AIIAHAB H =JE =?GKEIEJEA? IAHL=JE AE IEIJA EE B H =JE?E@A A= E EIJH= E EJEJ =HE 5EJH=JJ=@EK LAH AFH FHE F=JHE E?DA@ALAAIIAHAJKJA =J FAH = = JA AHA \E JACHEJ AGKE @E \=BBE@=>E EJ @A AE B H = E E FK>> E?DA >FHALA EHAA E EJ=HAE@= E@=E JHKIE EA=??AIIE=>KIELE?ALEJ=HAF IIE>E EJ @E@EBBKIE E =KJ HE =JA@EE B H = E E @? IA JEHAK? HHAJJ BK E = A J @A \=FF=H=J >KH?H=JE? A@ ALEJ=HAE JAHHK E E A \AH C= E A@AEIAHLE E E A IJAII??AJJ @EFK>> E?== E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= AIEB @=IK A?AII=HE A@E F E?EJ FHAIKFF IJ?DAIE= IE?KHEEIEIJA E AEGK= E I FH @ JJEA? IAHL=JEE@=JE

%& 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A =?A JH= EJ @A JA =@A =IE?KHA =@AEIEIJA EE B H =JELE@A AFK> > E?DA= E EIJH= E E AGKE @E@AE@=JEE AIIA? JA KJE JH L=? BAH = A \=HJ #@ CI & # 5EJH=JJ=@EK =@EIF IE E A@EFHE?EFE?DA FAH =@EI?EF E =@E@AJJ=C E HE = @== \=@ E A@A AHAC AJA? E?DAA = = @A=EIA IE@A \=HJ %@A + @E?A JKJJ=LE=E F HJ= JAI JJ E A=HA? AE J= A H =IE= E @E?=JEE FHE? FE?KEJ= EHAC A@AL K EB H =HIE =E JACHEJ A@AI=JJA =@AE@=JE 1@=JE?KIJ @EJE AEIEIJA E@AL AIIAHA @EBE?=JE A E E =JEI @=EI CCAJJE= \K F =>E EJ=JE GKE @E A?AII=HE?DAE IEIJA =IE=? CAC =J E @ J= A@=FHALA@AHA @ELAHIE ELA E@E=KJA JE?= E AA? IA JEHA? K GKA?DAHE = C= JH=??E=@A A@ELAHIA FAH= E EIL JA >@EIF E>E EJ A=??AIIE>E EJ 1@=JE@AL F JAHAIIAHABHKE>E E@= A = E EIJH= E EA@=E?EJJ=@E E?DA A=>>E= @EHEJJ?HEIAHL=JA =A? BE@A E= EJ 1 IEIJA =@ALAAIIAHAIJHKJJKH=J E @ @=ALEJ=HAE HEI?DE @E=??AIIE =KJ HE =JE -LE@A JA =BE = EJ @A = H = HE@KHHAEHEI?DE?DAF II @AHEL=HA @==JJE@ IE=@AI I=> J=CCE =??AIIE=>KIELE @=ALA JE=??E@A J= E? AAHH HE? FEKJE@= FAHI = A ALA JE?= = EJ IE 5E IIAHL=?DA \A = = @ HAC = A J JA? E?? JAHH AK E?DA H AE =JAHE=@EIE?KHA =E B H =JE?=@AEIEIJA EE B H =JELE @A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E 5K JA =@A =IE?KHA =E B H =JE?= A IAJJ HAFK>> E? E IEIJ CE JAF E?EFH LLA@E A JE ACCE @EHAJJELA?EH? =HE 1 = EJKJJ LE =@EI?EF E =E =JAHE=@EHEIAHL=JA =@AE@=JEFAHI = E@ CI '$!?DAFHALA@AK =IAHEA@E >> ECDE@EIE?KHA =FAH JKJJEEI CCAJJE FK>> E?E? AFHEL=JE?DA? FE= FAH= E E@EJH=JJ= A J @AE@=JEFAHI = E & 8EI F E A H AE =JAHE=@EIE?KHA =@AJJ=JA? HECK=H@ = IEIJA =@EFH J? E B H =JE? ACAIJE A@AEB KIIE@?K A J= E & 1 F=HJE? =HA LA C E HE EAL A@EIF IE E E? JA KJA AC E=HJJ!!!$A A @EI?E F E =HAJA? E? =@ JJ=J? \= AC=J *= @ CI '$! 8=HE AL=J? A FH FHE FAH C=H= JEHAE? H@E = A J? GKAIJA@EIF IE E E \=HJ % @ CI & # FHALA@A?DA \=@ E A@A AHAC AJA? E?DA@A>>==LLA EHAI @ F =LAHIA JEJ E /=H= JAFAH =FH JA E A@AE@=JEFAHI = E

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E %' AHEJ=F=HJE? =HA A E A I JJ GKAIJ FH BE \=HJ %, 2 +! JJ >HA E >=IA= GK= AEIEIJA EE B H =JE =JE@ECAIJE A@AEFH?A@E A JE= E EIJH=JELE@AL CE C=H= JEHA =IE?KH=A@K EL?=E@A JEBE?= E A@AC EKJA JE \=??AII = AHEI HIAI =C EKJA JE=>E EJ=JE \=??AII @E C EKJA JAI = AE B H = E EHA =JELA= IK ELA @E =KJA JE?= E A =HACEIJH= E A@EJKJJA A @EBE?DAABBAJJK=JA=E@=JEA@?K A JE@A IEIJA = @E @?DAIE=IA FHAF IIE>E AE @ELE@K=HA \=KJ HA@E J= E @EBE?DA \ABBAJJK= E A@E? FEA@EIE?KHA =@A? JA KJ @EHACEIJHEA=H?DELE + AIFAII =??=@A= \E B H =JE?=FK>> E?= = JAF E?EJ @EHAC A =EKJ=K \ABBAJJEL==FF E?= E A@A AIJAIIA ' 2AH=??HAI?AHAE ELA @EIE?KHA =E B H =JE?= A IAJJ HAFK>> E? =KIFE?=>E A?DA AHAC A JA? E?DA?DAI=H= =@ JJ=JA=EIA IE@A \=HJ %@A @ CI & # IE=??AFEJAE @ @=? IJEJKEHA \??=IE AFAHB H EHA= A= E EIJH= E EK IA F E?AFK J @EHEBAHE A J E JAH E E@E >> ECDEA@ =@A FE A JE # 24 52-6618- - 37-561 1 )2-46- 1 )6-41),1,152 1*1 16,-1,)61,- - 27** 1+0- ) 1 1564) 1 1 + A@EIF IE E EE =JAHE=@E@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JEJH L=BE = A JA? FE A J E FH?A@E A J @E]@A?AHJEBE?= E A^ =LLE=J? A ACCE @EIA F EBE?= E A= E EIJH=JEL=AFH IACKEJ? E 6AIJ 7 E? IK = @?K A J= E A= E EIJH=JEL=, 2 4 ""# /E \=HJ "!?, 2 4 ""# FHALA@AL= E B=JJE?DA] A ',ALAHE AL=HIE? AJKJJA AFHAI?HE E E@EIE?KHA ==>>E= E F E?= E E@EJEF JA? E? A@ HC= E =JEL FAH?KEI FAHE? IA AE KJE E@KF E?= E E *=IJEFA I=HA?DA A = E EIJH= E E@AL HA@ECAHA>A @KA@?K A JEIK =IE?KHA =? IJAII I? F L= KJ=HAE HEI?DE? HI @=EFH FHEIEIJA EE B H =JELEA@E @ELE@K=HAC E=?? HCE A JE@==@ J J=HA A= E EIJH= E E@AL E B=JJE? FE =HAE,?K A J 2H CH= =JE? IK = 5E?KHA =,25=EIA IE@A @ CI '$! =@AL =@ JJ=HA=?DAE 2E= IK =IE?K HA =E B H =JE?=FHALEIJ @= =,A E>AH= E A)12) # 5K =CH=LEJ @A =IEJK= E A=JJK= A?BH 1-48) \E IE?KHA =@AEIEIJA EE B H =JELEFK>> E?E E 1 JAH AN MMM E JAH AN EJ! $%

& 1 B H =JE?=A@EHEJJ 1 + @E?A@A \= E EIJH= E A@ECEJ= A = E EIJH= E EFK>> E?DAAECAIJ HE@EFK>> E?EIAHLE E F II HE?DEA@AHA=JJE?AHJEBE?=JE??AH A JEIJ=JE GK= EJ FAHI = E^ AB=JJE?DA IE= =JJAIJ=JEE @?K A JECE E H F IIAII?DA? K GKAAIIA IE= JA KJA=?AHJEBE?=HA 1 K C @EJ= E=JJE?AHJEBE?=JE AFK>> E?DA = E EIJH= E EI JA KJA=@=?GKEIEHA@\KBBE?E =?DAFAHLE= JA A =JE?=EHA =JELE@=JE \E JAHAII=J @ALAGKE @E? K E?=HAK =I =L J== \= E EIJH= E AE@=JEA AL=HE= E E@A AE B H = E E?DA HECK=H@= 5EF A GKE @E FAH A= E EIJH= E EE FH > A =@A \= E A= A J @AE@=JE?DA HECK=H@= E?EJJ=@E E 1 + @E?AIEFHA??KF=@E@ABE EHA \= E A= A J? A]E FH?AII @E? H@E = A J @AE@=JEFHAIA JEE FE =H?DELEBE = E =J = =LAHEBE?=@A =? HHEIF @A =@A AE B H = E EE AII? JA KJA^ =HJ AJJ = = @AI?HELA A @= EJ??KEJ= A= E A= A J @ALA=LLA EHA 5EJH=J J=@EK FH BE =II=EE F HJ= JA?DA F JH AIIAHAI JJ L= KJ=J E IA@A@E=@ E A@A AHAC AJA? E?DAE GK= J =EIA IE@A \=HJ %? AJJ = @A @ CI '$! \E JAHAII=J D=@EHEJJ =@ JJA AHA \]=CCE H = A J ^ A =]HAJJEBE?= E A^ @AEFH FHE@=JEFAHI = E *A IEFK? BECKH=HA GKE @E K LAH AFH FHE @EHEJJ @A?EJJ=@E @ECEJ= A= \= E A= A J @AE@=JEFK>> E?E?DA HECK=H@= ) JH FH BE FH > A =JE? @A FHE?EFE @E@EIF E>E EJ AC=J = H=FF HJ JH= = H =JEL=@AJJ=J=@= + @E?A AE CA AH= A@= = H =JE L=IJ=J= A? = ACEI = E AHACE = AE =JAHE= 5K FK J @ALAHEJA AH IE?DA = ACEI = E AIJ=J= AE GKAIJE A? IJEJKEI?=AIFHAIIE A@A = F JAIJ ACEI =JEL=AI? KIEL=IJ=J= A A = =JAHE=@A ]? H@E = A J E B H =JEL IJ=JEIJE? AE B H =JE? @AE@=JE@A \= E EIJH= E AIJ=J= A HACE = AA?= A^ AN=HJ %? AJJ H @A =+ IJEJK E A \=JJHE>K E A= ELA?A JH= A@EGKAIJ= =JAHE=IECEKIJEBE?=? = A?AIIEJ @E]=IIE?KH=HAK =? K = =@E E CK=CCE @EFH?A@KHAA@E IJ= @=H@ CA AE E @ @=FAH AJJAHA =? K E?=>E EJ JH=EIEIJA E E B H =JE?E@A =FK>> E?== E EIJH= E A^ 5EF A =GKAIJ FK J E FH > A =@A = ACEJJE EJ @A = H =JEL= HACE = AALA JK= A JACE @AJJ=J=FAH HC= E =HAEIEIJA EE B H =JELE + I + HJA? IJ % " A IJAII IA I?BH + HJA? IJ! #

- *A EI=HE =@EIF E>E EJ @AE@=JE@A AFK>> E?DA= E EIJH= E E & HACE = EA =@EIF E>E EJ @A F=JHE E E B H =JEL FK>> E? 1 FH F IEJ IE IIAHL=?DA =+ IK J=D=CE =LKJ @ @E=BBAH =HA? A JH=JJ= @ IE@EF JAHA ACEI =JEL @E? H@E = A J E IK =?=J AIAH?E E FHA? K@AL==KJ AE E E=JELA@A A4ACE E=LA JE=@ CCAJJ = H= E = AA@ABBE?=?A HC= E = E A@A A>=IE@E@=JE?DAI A = H @EIF E>E EJ A@=?DAE H? H@E = A J? A= = CDAIJHKJJKHA @AC E= JHEA JEFK>> E?EAFHEL=JE FAH= JEIK JAHHEJ HE HACE = A+ HJA + IJ % # 1 FH > A =I HCA A A J E?KE? A A?=I E AI= A E ACEI =J HA@AJJ= H =JEL=E GKAIJ = >EJ =BE E@E? H@E = A J \A JH=J=E LEC HA@EJ= E H A@AJAH E =@K GKAALA JK= EFH > A E @EE? IJEJK E = EJ @A A H =JELAHACE = EFHALECA JE =JKH= A JA CE L=HE>=@EH \AIAH?E E @=F=HA@A ACEI =J HAIJ=J= A @A =F JAIJ E =JAHE=@E? H@E = A J AI? K@A =? FAJA = HACE = A A =@EI?EF E =@A =CAIJE A@EK =FH FHE=HAJAE B H =JEL= + HJA? IJ # # 6= E H =JELA@ LH= E C E?=I B=HA AIFHAII HEBAHE A J = @ LAH I HEIFAJJ @A = H =JEL=IJ=J= A@E? H @E = A J?D @EGKA =F IJ==JKJA =@AE@=JEFAHI = E 1 GKAIJ IA I + HJA? IJ % #?DAD=@E?DE=H=J? IJEJK E = A JAE ACEJJE = =@EIF IE E A@A = ACCAHACE = A@A \- E E=4 =C = A =F=HJAE?KE @EI?EF E = @ E BK E = A J @A 5EIJA =1 B H =JEL 4ACE = A514 HE?DE= =L=AIFHAII= A JAE FEA HEIFAJJ @A = ACEI = E AIJ=J= AIK =FH JA E A@AE@=JEFAHI = E@ CI '$!