ISSN 1127-8579 Pubblicato dal 24/09/2012 All'indirizzo http://www.diritto.it/docs/33952-recurso-especial-an-lise-do-erro-na-valora-odas-provas Autori: Gabriela Póvoas, Jessica Fernanda Dias, Onísia Carmen Stoinski Póvoas Recurso especial: Análise do Erro na Valoração das Provas
ABC ADEF D F F D D D D D ABC D C CEF A C C C C C D A CE C C A CD C C C C C A C C D C CD C B D C A A C A C D C C C A DC A C FC C C D C C D E C A A C C A A C C C D C C C C A D C D A D A D A C A A D C A C C D C D DA A C C D D ABA A A C C A D C C C C ABC D A C C C C C D C CEF A C C C C C D A CE C C A CD C C C EAE ACB A A C C D C C D C AE A AC C C C D B AD C A D A C A AC D C D C D D C A E C C ADA D F D A C CD AC A C D E A C B D A A C C B C A A A C C CB C C A C C DA A C A E A A C C A A B D A A C C C C A AC C E A A D CA A C B A A E A A A D A A C D A A A E A D D A A C C C C C DC A C A A C A A C C C
C C A C C D C CD C B D C A A C A C D C C C A DC A C FC C C D C C D E C A A C C A A C C C D C C C C A D C D A A D A C A A A D C A C C D C D DA A C C C C D AD C A C CEF C A C A A A C D C C C F A C C C A A C A C CDC D AC A A C A C D C D A DC C A A C A AC D A C A A C C D AC F A C C AD D C C F C A D C C A C D C D A C C C F C C AE A B A A A D AD D DC AD C F A A C A A C C D C DE D F A A C C B C C C C A A D A C D A A C C C F A C C A C B A C C CDC A C EA AD C A C A C D A C AD C AC AE A A A A C A C C F A C A A B C D C B A C C A C F A C C C C CEF C A A C ABC DC A DEC AD C D C C A C CD A A EAE ACB A CA A A C C A A A A A A A C ABC C D A D A EC E D A C B CD A C A C A A CEF C A EAD C A A C C A DA AEA A C C A C A A A C D C C C C C A A ABC ADEF D F F F D
C A C D C C A A C ABC A A C E DE D C ABC C C A A ABC DE D A C C BAD C C C AC AE A ABC C ABC A C DC CD A A C B C A C C A A C CD A E C CD A C C A D A C C C B A A C AE A A A A C DA A C C A A C E C DE D CD A C A C CD A C C F B C C A CDC A C AD A C F A EAD C C A E A C A A C C A AC A C A CD D A B C A B D E A C D D F C C AC C A C C AE A D A A A C C C A DE D C A A F A A C F A A A A B A C A AE A CE C D DC C A A A C D D C C A C A AC A D C D A C D C C A AC C C CEF C A A C C AD C CD A F B D C C C AB D A C A A C ABC C A A EAD C A C A A C C A C CA D A D C C A CDC A A C B A B A A A CD D A C A A CE A A C C A DA B A C A A C C A C A A A D C AC C CE A D A C C B A B A A C DA A C C A A C A C A AC C D AC A C A EA A C CDC B A C C A A C CD D D A B A C A A C A C A DC C C A CDC D A DC C B A A C DA A C D C AE A C A BAC A A A C B A C C C ABA
A BCDEF CFB BCBDE C E C B B BF FA B A EC B CB E F EC B CB FCFE C B B EB BCB FC C BE F C E C B BC B CFB E BC B B F B C B A C B B DC B B EBD FC B AB E EA F AB B B BCB ED F E C BE F F C E CBC F CB B B A B EA AE E B B EBD FC B B FB A BCB F A F C B CB F B E C B B B E BF A E B B C B CB E C B B F C B F E B B BCB C B CBA FC CB CAB F C AB F E CA B A CF B BA B B E CF B B BF FA B A EC B F BD B B B E BC B F CFB E B BA E B CB E B CFB CBDE C E C BE EC CBC E CB E C C B BF FA B A EC B CB E F ECB C B AA EB CBDE C E C B B A BDE B EFCB B F B CB F A F C B BE F AA AB F FE AB BF FF B C A C C A A B A C DC A A D C C C A C A A A A B A F A A D D DC A C A A C B AD A B A F C C D C C C A C A A C C C A C A A C EF A C C D A C D C A C C C C C A C C C A A AD A C C A A B A C A A C A A A C A AC A D A D A A A AC C A AB C D AC A C B F D A C A A C D EC ADF A A C CD E C A C B C BA BE F B BF FA B A EC B B CA B CBC CB C BB BE EA AB B BCF B B CB B FCFE C B B EB BCB FC C BE F C E C B A B B B EA AE E B E C B BA FBE E C B BF FA BA B CB B BA FBC E E B BF FA B B B E B FB BDC CFB B AB F EAE AB BC EAAE E E C B D C C A A A A C DA A C C A A C D DEA C AC D C CEF A C D A C A A C A DC A C A D F A C A B A C D C A A A C DA A C A C AE A C AD CD C A C A A D A C D A D D C C A A C C DC C A D AD D A C C B F A A C D C C C A A A C A C C A A C
C D CEF C C A A C AD C A A A C F C A C D A E C C A AC C A C C C AE A C C C A A C C A AC A AD A C B A AD A A C D DC B C B A A AD B C C C C C CD C D C A DE D C A D F A C A A C A C AE A A A A C E C A C A A C D AE A AC AC CD CD A D C E AB D C A C A AD A A C A D C C A C A A D D A A C A C C A C A C C B C C C D D A AD B A A A C C A AC A C A A C D A A A C C C C ADA C C CEF C C C AC A A C C C C C AC CD F B D C C C C A DE C C C C A A C D AC AD B C C EAD C C D C C A F C D C C C A C C B C C D DC C A C C D AC C C A C A D D C D C D A A C C CD CE D A A C A A A A C C C C E A C AB C A DA C D DC A A C C AC A C A BA D A A A C ADA C CD A C A AC D A C F A A C CEF C C A C C A C C A C B AB A F B A A C C BC C C C C D A A A C A B F AE C C C AE
A CA A C D A C AD A ADA A EAD C C C A D A C A A C C A A C E C A AD CDC C C A AC C C D C A CA C D D A D A C A A C D A B A D C C A C D A ABA A C AD B C AD A EAD C C C C D D C A C AC C C C A C C C C D DA AEA A A C A AC C DC C C C C AC D A C C C D B C C C D C A AC A C CD C AC AE A F B D C A A A D A C AD A A C AE A BAC A A C C AE A C C C A A C A AC C A C C A C A C C A C B AB A E F B A A C C BC C C C C D A A A C A B F AE C C C AE A AD A D A C A C A C A C A A C C A AC C C C A D CDC A A DA A C C AC C C A C D A C A C D A AE A C C C A C A C C A AC AD C D ED A C AD C A C AD C A A A CD C D B C C C A A C C A A C A C D A C D C C AC A C A C C CE C B D C
C A C B A AB A E C C A C B C D CD D AD A A D C C D B A C A AC C A A A C C A A C C D A A C D C A DE D D A A C C A CE A C A AC C A A C A C DA C C A C C C A CB C A C C C A AC A C A C A AC C E C C A CDE F A A C C D C C C B A C A C A D E DA A C C C D C A A C C DC C C C A A C C C A C B C C C C C C A C A C DA C C A A C A C AE A E DA A C C A C DA AEA A B C C C C D A B C A D C F A A C C A A C E C C C C C C A B C A D C D A C C C C F A D A AB C A A C A C C C C C A A C CD A C C D A C A DA AEA A C C C A D F C C A D D A C DA A C AD B A A C C CD A A C C F B D C C C C A C A E C A A C C D A C C AE A E C A A C C C C C BC C C C C C A C C AC A C E C A A B A C A C C C C C A A A D C DEA C C AE CEF A C C C C A A CD A C CA D C C A D A C C D A A A C D CE A A A A A D A A A
C E AFE E E E A A C C C C A C C D B C DA A A C A C C C A C A A A A D A A A C E DA D A B C A C C D CE D CD A C A AC CA A A C C C D A C BC C C D A C C B D AD C A AC CA C D C D A A C C A C CD A BA A A C C C C C A C A C C F FA F A C A AC A A C C E C C C A AC CD D C E C A C A AC A C C A C C CD C A D A C C C A AC AFE B CD C A C DA C A C C A A C C A AE A C C ADC ADC A C A A C C A F FA E A AC C EAD C C C A D A C D A CDC D C C A A D A D A CE EA A D A C D AC A D A C C A C A A D A C C AE A A C D D C D A C A C A C C A AD A A C C A F C C CD D C C C C C A C D A C ABD F C A D C C C A C F B C C D A C C C A C D C A AC C A C A C A AC C C AD C C C E C D A C A AC CD A C C A B CD C A CD D C C A A C C C E A D A C C A A B C C A C C C AE A DE D B DC A C A D C C A C CDC ABD C C A A C C A C C D C C C A
F F D C A A C C C C DC A CDC C DE D C A A C A C C EC DC E D B C A A C A C D A A C ABC C A A C C A C C A A C C C A DC C A A C C A F D D D DE C C D A A A C D CD C C C D A C AEA A A C A C C C C A AC C A C C C AC A C C A AC BC D C A A C A A C C C C DC C C DA AEA A C A C AEA A A C F A A C C AC D D C B A C F A A A E A A DA A C A D A D A C C CD B C F A A AC A A AC A C C C D F A A A B BAC F D C C D A DA C C C A AC C C E F A C AB D C C A AC C AD B C AC D C ABC C C A A DC C A C C C C A C A A C C C C A F B D C C D AC A C C C C D A C C AD D DE BC A A B C C A AC C A A C CE C C F B D C C C A A C DA AEA A C A C C C A D ABC C D D D A A C D A C C C C E C D D C
C A A E E ABA D DC C C C AC D C C D FC C C C A AC F C C DC AE A C B A D CE D A D C C CDA C A C CE C C C D C C C DE BC AC C C CEF C C C A AC C C A A C C AC D C D C DA C C DC C C A A C C A C A C A C A A C A AC CE C C C C A C A D A D CB C AC D C A A C D A A C EAD C C C AC A C C C A C A AC C A AC C C C C DC C C AC D C C AC D C A A C A AC A D B C B BA C C A A C C A D C AC D C AC A A A A C C A A A A C A CE C C C A AC C D C ABA C C AE A AC A D AC D C D A C EDA C D A A A C A A AB A C A C C AC A AB A C AC D C D DC C D D A C D E A D A AC C D B A D C D B F A A C AC D C C C D A C AD A C AD A C C AE C AB D DA F C C A C C D A C C C ED A C A C C AC D C AD A C C C C D C AE A E D D AC D A C CEF C C C AC A CA C C A AD D BC C C EAE ACB A A CE C D DC C ADC A D C A C C C
A F C C A C D C C C D C A A A AB A A A C D F C C DA A C C AC AE A F EA D C C C A C D A A A C A D A A A AE A D B BA D A C C AE CBC A C D C AD D C C F C A A C C B D A C C DA A C A A AD C AEA A C C C AD C C C A C C F B D C C D A C C C C C D BA C CE D C D C C C C C A A D DA A C A C A C C C AD A C D C C CAEA C D C A C C C D C B A D DC A A C C CD A C C A C D CA A C A C C E C C C A C C D C CD C B D D B D C C A C BA A C A C A A A D E C A A C C A A C C C DC CEF C E AD A C C C F C A D C C AD D C C F C A D C D DC AD C F A A C A A C C D A D C DE D F A A C C B C C C C A A D A C D A A C C C F A C C A C B A C C CDC A C EA AD C A C A C D A C AD C AC AE A A A A C A C C F A C A A B C D C B A C C A C F A C C C C CEF C A A C ABC A C DC A DEC AD C
C A C A D C C A DA C D C C A D A A A C C E C C C C A F A B C C C C D C D A C D A C C E C D C C CE A AC A C C C A C B A A C D A A A C C C C D C AEA A C A E C C CE A D A A A C C C DA D C A C C C C AC D A A A A A C A A C C C A AB C AE A CD C AD C AC C D A A C C A C C AD A C D D A C DEC CE C D C A C EF C F A B A C D C F A C A C D C AC A C C A A C D A A D A C C D ABA C A A BC A C D C C C C F B D C AC C AE C DA C C C A C C A AC D AC A C C ADA A A A D A C D D C C C C C D B C C D DC C D AB A A A C C C C C C C A A C A A C C C DC C C AC D C C F C C A C C C D A C A C A A C C AB A A A C C C D C B A AC E A C C D D E C D C C CD C C A A A A C A A C A A CA D A A A C C C C C AC A C A D C D DC C A A C C DC C C C C A A C A A C C C A CDC C C A D C C A C C DA C AD C C C C A A C A A B A D C D C C C C A A A C D C C DE D CEF C C C DC CD C C A A C C C A A D D A C A A C E C C A A AD AC C
A A C C C C AB C C A A C D A D A B C C C C D C C D D C AD C A A C C C C A A C D E C A C AEA A C D AC C C DC C C A C C A D C AB F A C E C C F C C A A C D A A D A C C D ABA C C A A A BC A C D C C C C F B D C AC C AE C DA C C C C A AB C A A C C A A C D B C A D C F A C D D C C A C D C D F A CE FC AB A A C C AD C A C A B A C C CA C C A C C C D C C CD C C D A C C C C C A AC A AC D A A C D C C ABA C A C AB C C A A A F C D D C A C C C AD C A C CE D D C D F A C D AC A C C D A C A A A A B A D C C D C A A C C C A F A E C C A A AC C C C C A C A A A C D A D CA D C D C D A A B A A D C D C C C C A C C CE A C A A D DA C C D C C C F DA C C CE A C D AC A A C D A A A C AD C A D F B C C DE C C C C D C A DC A C A A A C DA A C C A E C C C C C D C C C C C B A C C AD C AD C AEA A D B C AC B A D C AD C F C D C A C EC B A C D F F E C A A C A F A C A B C C C C A C C C C D A A CE A C D C C DA A C A DA C C C A C C
C C DA A C A A C A C A A C F A A C C D D AC C C C C AE A C C DA A C C D C D A C C C A C CE AC D A A C D C D C C C A C C A C D F F E C A A C A F A C A C C C C C DA D C C C B C E A F A E F B D C C C C D C DA A C C C E A E A A C C A C C C C C C E E E C C C CD A C C F A C D CEF C C A C C C C A A D AE A C A C C F A C C A C C C CE F D C A C A A C A A A D A D C A C C DA A C A A C D F F E C A A C A F A C A D C A B C C C C C A D D C A A C C C A C E C C D DC C A C CDA AC C C C C A C D F F E E F C C F A D C D C C A D C C C A C D C A C D CDC A A A CD C D A B C C A C DE B C C D AC A C D C A C A E C C DC C A C F B D C C C C C C DA A C A A E C C D C E C C A C B A A C A C C A B C D DA A A A D B C B D C A C A B D C A C C E C C A C D F F E C A A C A F A C A C C D C C C A AC C A C AD C AB D C C A C C C C C CD C A AC C A C AD C C CD C DA A C A C A C C EF A C D BA C A D C C C C C C C C E D A C
A AC C A C AD C C C C C D BA C C A A B C C A D C ECD C BA A A A C C C C ADC A A C C C C AC A EA A A C C DA A C D A ADA DC D AC C D A C C AD A D DE D F C A C C C C C A C C D C C A A D C C DA A C C A D C DC AE E C D B C C C C C C F B D C C AE A C C C A C C C D C AE A A C D F F E E F C C F A E CA CE A AEA A C C A A A CD D A C E A C C A C D D D C A C D C A A C D C C DA A C C A C C C C E D C A C A D D C AEA A A C C C C A C A A A C D A AC C C C A D A D C C C C A C CD D C D C C C F D A A D A C C A C C A C C C C C A C D F F E E F C C C C CD C DA A C C C C A A C C A A A C C C C C C AC C D DA A C C A D C F B D C C C DE B C C C C C C A DC A D C B C CD C ABC A C C A C C C DC EA C A A C A A C C DC A C D F F E E F C C F A CEF A C AD A C E AD C D A A C C DC AD C D BA C C D A A AD CDC EA D C C C C DC ADC C C EA C A C C C C A C EA A C C A C D A C C E C DC C D A C C DA C DC EA C C AE A E A C D B A A CE D A A A C A A A F A A A C AD A A C C EA
C C ABC A C C A C E A A D D CE C C DE B C C C C A C D F F E E F C C F A C A C D C C D D F B D C C C C AD C D C A C F A C C DA A C D C C C A AC D D C F B D C C C A AB A A C A C C C E A C C C B A A A C D F F E E F C C F A C DA A C AC B A EC A CDC C C A C C F A A C C BC C B C A D CDC A A C A C D F F E E F C C F A C C CD C DA A C C C C C A C D C A D DCD C B D BC C D C A C C A C C C C AE BAC BA C CD E BC AD C A C E C A C AD A C B CD A C DC C A C A C C A C D C C AD C C D DC A C C C AD C F CE A C C D DC D E C CE C C C E C C C AD C A A A CDC F A C A C C C A C BC C EAE ACB A A C C D D D C D A C D C D C A C C D E D D DC D C C DC C A D A A CD C C C C A A C C D A A DA C A A C CD F DC A C A C A D D A C C A D C C AB D AD C C C C C DC C A E C C A A C A D AB C A D D A C A A C CA C E C A A AD AC C A A C C C C AB C C A A C D A D A B C C C C D C D D C AD C
C C C D C C A A A D A C A C C C C C C C A C D A A F A C AE A AC D A AB AB C C A A C D A A D A C C D ABA C A A BC A C D C C C C F B D C AC C AE C DA C C C AD C AE A D C A A C C C C D DE D C D C C A C C C C C C D A DC E C D C C C C A A AC C ADC C A C D DE D A C A AC E A C A A C A D C A AC C A AC A C A A C A A C B A EA A C A A A C C C E A D CD C A C C C A C F F A C C D D A C C D DC C C D C C CE D F A C C C A C C A B A F A A E D C A C C D C C C BC C C C F A C CB C C CDC C CA C A A C C C C A AC AC C A A C C C C A AC A EA A C A A C D AB C C E E E A C C A A C C D C C A A C C C A A C C A C C C B C AD CD D A A A C A C A A C A A C C C B A C A AC C C CE AB C C A D C DC C DA A A A C D C D DC C D A D C A A C C C C AD C C D DA A C A A C E A C C C C CD AB A C A AC C C C A A C C C A A C C A C C C C C AC AE A A A D C C C C D A D C C A C C C C C D A A C C AC AE A D CE AB C A F B CE B C C C A B A C C AD C C A AC CD A C CE AC F A A AC DE D C C F A C A A C A A C A D C C C D A F A A AC C
A A C AD A C C C D FC A C C A A C C A AD A DA AEA A C A CE C D C D D D A A D A C A A C C C C A A F A D AD A C C C DC C C C C C F A A C C C C C D A AB A A D C C D AD C A A C F A A AC F A C D A C C A C C C C C DC C AB A A A A C A C F A A A C D A C F A A AC A B A AC C A C F C C A C A C D F D C C A C A C AE A A A C D D D DE A A A E A A A F A A A B E A F A E A A A C A A A C A AC A F F F C C A A A D A AD F D A C A C AB B F D C C A C C C C C C A AC C C CE C AD F F D D F A C D F E C B C AC E C D BC
C A D F C C A C A C DE C F F AC A C C E C D D F D A CC A A C C A A C D F F E C A A C A F A C A A A D A C C D A A C A A A C D F F E E F C C F A D B C D A A C A A C D F F E E F C C F A D B C D A A C C C A C D F F E E F C C F A D B C D A A C AC B A EC A C D F F E E F C C F A D B C D D C A C D F F E D A C F C D C A D C A C D F E C D C A C F A A D BA D C D D C A C D F E C D C A C F A A D BA D C D D C A C D F E C D C A C F A A D BA D C D